How to Sell St Gaudens Double Eagle Gold Coins

To sell St. Gaudens Double Eagle coins, start by getting a professional appraisal to determine their value, then research reputable buyers who offer secure, transparent transactions. For the safest, most profitable experience, Coinfully’s expert appraisals and global buyer network make them the top choice.

The Saint Gaudens Double Eagle is one of America’s most iconic and valuable gold coins, cherished by collectors and investors alike.

Whether you own a single coin or an extensive collection, understanding how to sell gold coins like St. Gaudens Double Eagles safely and profitably is essential.

This guide walks you through everything from the coin’s rich history and value factors to the best way to sell your gold coins, helping you make informed decisions and secure the highest possible return on your investment.

How to Sell St Gaudens Double Eagle Gold Coins: Key Steps

Selling a St. Gaudens Double Eagle successfully requires more than just knowing its gold weight—it involves understanding the market, accurately assessing the coin’s value, and handling logistics carefully. The steps below will help you prepare and protect your investment.

Getting Your Coins Graded and Appraised

When appropriate, you can begin by having your coins professionally appraised and graded by a recognized third-party grading service such as PCGS or NGC.

These organizations assess a coin’s authenticity and condition, which directly influences market value. A certified grade can provide legitimacy and potentially increase buyer offers. Always consult with an appraiser first as certain pieces will not need grading. For common date and lower condition pieces, grading may require time and fees that will not add value to sale value.

Preparing Your Coins for Sale

To preserve their condition, avoid cleaning or polishing your St. Gaudens Double Eagle gold coins—this can cause damage and reduce value.

Handle coins by the edges using gloves, and store them in non-PVC holders or hard plastic capsules. Documenting provenance and organizing any paperwork adds professionalism to your sale.

Researching Potential Buyers

Look for buyers who specialize in rare gold coins or numismatics. Verify credentials, read online reviews, and compare offers from multiple sources.

Transparency, responsiveness, and a clear explanation of their evaluation process are good signs of a reputable buyer. Avoid high-pressure tactics or vague pricing structures.

Best Shipping Practices

When shipping coins, package them securely using bubble wrap or coin holders and place them in a sturdy box.

Always use a tracked, insured shipping method with signature confirmation. Retain proof of shipment and insurance coverage in case of damage, loss, or disputes during transit.

Securing Payment

Choose a secure payment method such as bank wire, or verified digital transfer. Confirm payment terms in writing before sending your coin.

Avoid accepting personal checks or unverified online payments, which may carry risk. Secure documentation protects both parties in the transaction.

$20 Saint Gaudens Double Eagle Coins

The $20 Saint Gaudens Double Eagle is widely considered one of the most beautiful coins ever produced in American coinage. Designed by renowned sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens, this iconic gold double eagle coin was struck in 90% gold and weighs nearly a full ounce.

Its obverse features a bold Lady Liberty holding a torch and olive branch, with the Capitol in the background and sun rays radiating outward. The reverse of the coin depicts a majestic eagle in flight, soaring above the rising sun.

Admired for its stunning design, historical relevance, and intrinsic gold value, the Saint Gaudens is a cornerstone of many collector portfolios and a prized asset for those dealing in rare gold coinage.

Coin History

First minted in 1907, the St. Gaudens Double Eagle emerged from President Theodore Roosevelt’s desire to redesign U.S. coinage into art-worthy masterpieces.

He personally selected sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens, who had previously worked on national monuments, to elevate the nation’s coin designs.

Though Saint-Gaudens died in 1907, his vision was realized with a striking high relief design that initially proved challenging for the Mint’s production process.

Later versions were flattened for mass production, and the coins were minted through 1933, when the government ceased gold coinage amid the Great Depression. Over time, the coin has become a symbol of early 20th-century artistry and a highlight of numismatic achievement.

St. Gaudens Double Eagle Coin Value

The value of a $20 double eagle gold coin can range widely depending on several critical factors, including condition, mintage, and market demand. While the gold content gives these coins a solid melt value, their collectible worth often far exceeds their weight in gold.

Certain dates, mintmarks, and rarities can make individual coins worth thousands—or even hundreds of thousands—of dollars. The 1933 Saint Gaudens Double Eagle coin holds the esteemed position of being the most expensive coin ever sold to the tune of $18.9 million!

Understanding what contributes to a St. Gaudens Double Eagle value is essential whether you’re a seasoned gold investor or selling for the first time.

Coin Condition

A coin’s physical state dramatically influences its market value. Uncirculated or Mint State coins often command far higher prices than worn examples.

Even light surface wear can decrease value significantly. Grading evaluates luster, strike sharpness, and contact marks, which are important metrics for determining worth above melt.

Mint Year

While all Saint Gaudens coins were minted between 1907 and 1933, some years are far rarer and more desirable.

The 1908 issues are particularly noteworthy because they were the first to include the motto “In God We Trust,” reflecting a significant political and cultural shift driven by Roosevelt-era values.

Mintmark

Where a coin was produced plays a critical role in its rarity. Saint Gaudens coins struck in Denver, San Francisco, and Philadelphia show different levels of scarcity.

For example, coins bearing the “D” or “S” mintmark can have far lower mintages, making them more sought after by collectors than their Philadelphia counterparts.

Proof vs. Circulation Strike

Proof coins were specially made for collectors with mirror-like finishes and sharp details. These are far rarer and more valuable than regular circulation strikes.

Only a small number of proof Saint Gaudens coins were made each year, making them exceptional pieces in any high-end numismatic collection.

Rarity and Demand

Coins with exceptionally low mintages, unusual errors, or historic provenance are in high demand. For instance, certain dates were struck in such small quantities that only a few examples survive.

Because such coins rarely appear for sale, competition among buyers drives their prices well above average.

Certified Coins

Third-party authentication and grading by organizations such as PCGS or NGC can significantly boost a coin’s credibility and value. Certified coins are verified for authenticity and condition, providing confidence to buyers.

Whether selling a single gold coin or an entire gold collection, certification helps maximize return.

Pricing Ranges for a Saint Gaudens Double Eagle Gold Coin

The Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle gold coin value can vary widely based on condition, date, strike type, and rarity. Though the base melt value provides a foundation, many coins carry significant numismatic premiums due to historical importance and collector demand.

Circulated Common-Date Coins: Typical circulated Saint-Gaudens coins from high-mintage years sell for $3,000 to $3,300, closely tied to their gold content.
Uncirculated Coins (MS60–MS63): In the past, standard uncirculated examples commanded a premium over melt., At the time of publishing this article, the historically high price of gold has absorbed this premium.
High Relief Coins (1907): The original high relief design ordered by President Theodore Roosevelt and executed by engraver Augustus Saint-Gaudens is highly collectible, with values from $9,000 to $30,000+, depending on grade.
Proof Strikes: Official proof Saint-Gaudens coins were struck in limited quantities and are exceptionally rare, commanding prices between $26,000 and $100,000+.
Rare Date & Mintmark Issues: Scarce combinations, and low-mintage issues such as 1920-S, 1921, and 1926-D, can reach values above $10,000, even in circulated condition.
Top-Population Examples (MS67+): Pristine coins with the highest grades can bring enormous premiums, especially if tied to a desirable date or pedigree.
Special Historical Relevance: Coins that reflect the artistic vision of President Theodore Roosevelt and feature national ideals resonate with collectors.
Denomination Context: While these coins carry a $20 face denomination, their real-world value reflects a blend of gold content, beauty, and American legacy far beyond the stamped amount.

The Problem With Traditional Selling Venues

Traditional selling venues, such as local coin shops and dealers, online marketplaces, and regional auction houses, often fall short when it comes to maximizing value and minimizing risk.

These outlets typically operate with limited buyer networks and high overhead, which can result in significantly lower offers. Traveling with a valuable coin collection also introduces serious security concerns, especially for six-figure assets.

Shipping coins to unknown buyers carries its own risks, including potential loss or damage. Also, many sellers encounter vague pricing structures or work with individuals lacking formal numismatic credentials.

Without access to a competitive marketplace or professional expertise, sellers are often left accepting subpar deals simply to avoid hassle. These limitations make traditional options ill-suited for high-value or historically significant coins like the Saint Gaudens Double Eagle.

The Best Way To Sell St. Gaudens Gold Double Eagles is Coinfully

When it comes to selling rare and valuable coins such as the Saint Gaudens Double Eagle, nothing is more important than safety, transparency, and maximizing your return. That’s exactly what we deliver at Coinfully.

Our process was designed from the ground up to eliminate the risks, guesswork, and inefficiencies that plague traditional selling methods.

As an online-only company with a global reach, we’re able to offer higher payouts by keeping overhead low and connecting your coins to our vast global network of collectors and professional buyers.

But it’s not just about what we offer—it’s how we offer it. From our no-pressure evaluations to our concierge-level service, everything we do is built around your comfort and confidence.

Whether you want to sell one Saint-Gaudens coin or an entire six-figure collection, we offer two distinct options to help you do it securely and smartly.

Concierge At-Home Appraisal Service

If your collection qualifies, we’ll send one of our licensed numismatic experts directly to your home or secure location free of charge. This level of service is unique to Coinfully and was created to eliminate the stress and risk of transporting valuable coins.

We understand how nerve-wracking it is to walk into unfamiliar shops with coins worth thousands or to hand off a package to the postal service and just hope for the best. That’s why our at-home service has become the gold standard in modern coin selling.

Our expert will take the time to evaluate each piece in your collection, explain its value, and answer every question. You’re never pressured to sell. If you do decide to move forward, we’ll issue a check or initiate secure electronic payment right then and there.

Free No-Obligation Online Appraisals

If your collection doesn’t meet the threshold for an in-person visit, our fully remote online appraisal service still offers a safe, accurate, and pressure-free experience.

Just send us clear photos and details of your Saint-Gaudens Double Eagles. One of our professional numismatists will review your submission and provide a detailed valuation, completely free and with zero obligation to sell.

We’ll walk you through how we arrived at our offer, breaking down the value of each coin and how we plan to resell it.

We insure all shipments through Lloyd’s of London, and once your coins are in hand, they’re verified under high-resolution security cameras for complete protection.

As soon as your coins are authenticated, we send your payment immediately via check or secure bank transfer. The entire process is fast, fair, and designed entirely around your peace of mind.

Other Options & Associated Risks

While there are several ways to sell a Saint Gaudens Double Eagle, most come with hidden drawbacks.

Limited reach, unclear pricing, security concerns, and lack of numismatic expertise can lead to disappointing offers—or worse. For those looking to protect their investment, these options often fall short.

Local Coin Shops and Dealers

While convenient, most local shops have limited buying power and small customer bases. Their overhead costs cut into your payout, and few are equipped to assess high-value coins like St. Gaudens Double Eagles properly.

Many sellers walk away with far less than their collection is worth.

Online Marketplaces

Platforms like eBay or Facebook Marketplace may offer direct access to buyers, but they come with major risks, including scams, chargebacks, and buyer fraud.

Shipping valuable coins to strangers without insurance or professional oversight can result in costly losses, with little to no recourse for the seller.

Coin Auctions

Major auctions often charge high fees, sometimes 15–20% or more, and payouts often take months.

You also lose control over the final sale price, as coins may sell for less than expected depending on bidder turnout. Lower-value coins often get little exposure or bidding attention.

Private Investors

Selling directly to investors may seem appealing, but without third-party verification or competitive offers, it’s easy to be taken advantage of.

Many private buyers target sellers who are unfamiliar with current market values, and there’s usually little transparency in how offers are calculated.

Making the Smart Choice for Your Double Eagle Coins

After weighing the risks and drawbacks of traditional selling methods, it’s clear that choosing a partner with industry expertise, transparent pricing, and secure processes isn’t just wise—it’s essential.

The right choice protects your investment and ensures you receive the true value your St. Gaudens Double Eagles deserve.

Trust Coinfully for Selling Gold Coins, Silver Coins, and Valuable Coin Collections

With years of numismatic expertise and a commitment to transparent, no-pressure service, Coinfully offers a secure, streamlined process from start to finish that’s designed to maximize your coins’ value.

Our global network of professional buyers and fast, reliable payments make selling gold, silver, and rare collections simple, safe, and rewarding.

Ready to get started? Contact Coinfully today to get an accurate appraisal and a top-of-market offer for your coins.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Double Eagle coin?

A Double Eagle is a U.S. gold coin with a $20 face value, first minted in 1849. The Saint Gaudens Double Eagle, designed by Augustus Saint-Gaudens in 1907, is famed for its artistic beauty and historical significance, featuring Lady Liberty and an eagle in flight.

How much is a Double Eagle coin worth?

Value depends on condition, rarity, and gold content. Common circulated coins are worth near gold melt value (~$3,400+), while rare dates, proof coins, or high-grade examples can fetch tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars at auction.

Why is the 7.6-million-dollar Double Eagle coin so valuable?

This coin is a unique 1933 Double Eagle coin, one of the few Saint Gaudens coins never officially released. Its extreme rarity, historical intrigue, and legal battles, combined with its pristine condition, make it one of the most valuable coins ever sold.

Are St. Gaudens a good investment?

Yes, Saint Gaudens coins combine intrinsic gold value with collectible appeal. Their artistic design, limited mintages, and historical importance often lead to steady appreciation, making them a sought-after asset for both investors and numismatic collectors.

The post How to Sell St Gaudens Double Eagle Gold Coins appeared first on Coinfully - the Best Way to Sell Coins | Free Appraisals.

Original post here: How to Sell St Gaudens Double Eagle Gold Coins